Chief’s Counsel: The Supreme Court Goes Back to the Future in Deciding the Constitutionality of Using GPS Technology

The January 23, 2012, U.S. Supreme Court decision in United States v. Jones1 concerning the use of a global positioning system (GPS) tracking devices raises more questions than it answers for use of expanding technology by law enforcement. As technology moves ever forward and expectations of privacy seem to be dwindling, the Jones decision refocuses the understanding of what constitutes a search back to the legal trespass principles in use at the time the Fourth Amendment was adopted. This rearward-looking approach to defining what constitutes a search will require law enforcement agencies to recalibrate their understanding of what privacy a person can reasonably expect, when their use of technology rises to the level of a search, and how best to employ emerging technology consistent with this old take on new trends. As technology advances toward a point where any aspect of a person’s life can be monitored by the government without much effort, the court makes it clear that it will analyze privacy and Fourth Amendment intrusions applying 18th century notions of privacy.

Read More
Chief's Counsel
Share
Words matter. The terms used to describe police work—law enforcement, public safety, guardian, protector, or warrior—do more than signal a philosophy. They define the profession’s purpose, s...
Chief's Counsel
Share
On May 15, 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a landmark decision in Barnes v. Felix, fundamentally altering the legal evaluation of excessive force claims under the Fourth Amendment. The ruling reje...
Chief's Counsel
Share
In 2025, “pig butchering” does not necessarily result in pork chops and bacon. The term now describes a sophisticated cybercrime that combines long-term psychological manipulation with fraudulent ...
Chief's Counsel
Share
In light of the recent U.S. government actions related to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), it is important for police leaders to be mindful of their ongoing obligations to comply with state and...
Chief's Counsel
Share
Facial recognition technology (FRT) emerged 50 years ago from experiments that measured facial attributes to search for matches on a semi-automated system.1 Modern FRT is an electronic system that us...
Chief's Counsel
Share
The Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution requires that criminal defense attorneys provide a minimum quality of service to their clients.1 The attorney need not be perfect but must at least be com...
Chief's Counsel
Share
Many police agencies already have or are looking into peer-to-peer counseling programs to assist first responders in dealing with the trauma that accompanies critical incidents. While these programs m...
Chief's Counsel
Share
Recent surveys and studies indicate a notable percentage of police officers experience and are affected by job-related stress and anxiety, in addition to stress stemming from personal matters. These s...
Chief's Counsel
Share
The image is familiar. A crowd is gathered, yelling and forming a circle around an intersection. Mere feet away, vehicles slide, smoke, and spin, accelerating in a circle at a high rate of speed. Pass...
Chief's Counsel
Share
The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) is a U.S. civil rights law that protects the rights of individuals with disabilities. Title II of the ADA prohibits public entities from excluding any...